| No. | Jugador | Puntos | Años | Equipo(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Adam Vinatieri+ | 2,673 | 1996-2019 | NE, Ind |
| 2 | Morten Andersen+ | 2,544 | 1982-2007 | NO, Atl, NYG, KC, Min |
| 3 | Gary Anderson | 2,434 | 1982-2004 | Pit, Phi, SF, Min, Ten |
| 4 | Jason Hanson | 2,150 | 1992-2012 | Det |
| 5 | John Carney | 2,062 | 1988-2010 | TB, LAR, SD, NO, Jax, KC, NYG |
| 6 | Matt Stover | 2,004 | 1991-2009 | Cle, Bal, Ind |
| 7 | George Blanda+ | 2,002 | 1949-1975 | Chi, Colts, Oilers, Oak |
| 8 | Jason Elam | 1,983 | 1993-2009 | Den, Atl |
| 9 | John Kasay | 1,970 | 1991-2011 | Sea, Car, NO |
| 10 | Robbie Gould | 1,961 | 2005-2022 | Chi, NYG, SF |
| 11 | Mason Crosby | 1,939 | 2007-2023 | GB, NYG |
| 12 | Sebastian Janikowski | 1,913 | 2000-2018 | Oak, Sea |
| 13 | Matt Prater | 1,908 | 2007-2025 | Atl, Den, Det, Az, Buf |
| 14 | Stephen Gostkowski | 1,875 | 2006-2020 | NE, Ten |
| 15 | Phil Dawson | 1,847 | 1999-2018 | Cle, SF, Az |
| 16 | Nick Folk | 1,826 | 2007-2025 | Dal, NYJ, TB, NE, Ten |
| 17 | Justin Tucker | 1,775 | 2012-2024 | Bal |
| 18 | Matt Bryant | 1,758 | 2002-2019 | NYG, Ind, Mia, TB, Atl |
| 19 | Norm Johnson | 1,736 | 1982-1999 | Sea, Atl, Pit, Phi |
| 20 | David Akers | 1,721 | 1998-2013 | Was, Phi, SF, Det |
| 21 | Nick Lowery | 1,711 | 1978-1996 | NE, KC, NYJ |
| 22 | Jan Stenerud+ | 1,699 | 1967-1985 | KC, GB, Min |
| 23 | Ryan Longwell | 1,687 | 1997-2012 | GB, Min, Sea |
| 24 | Lou Groza+ | 1,608 | 1946-1967 | Cle |
| 25 | Eddie Murray | 1,594 | 1980-2000 | Det, KC, TB, Dal, Phi, Was, Min |
| 26 | Al Del Greco | 1,584 | 1984-2000 | GB, Az, Ten |
| 27 | Olindo Mare | 1,555 | 1997-2012 | Mia, NO, Sea, Car, Chi |
| 28 | Steve Christie | 1,476 | 1990-2004 | TB, Buf, SD, NYG |
| 29 | Pat Leahy | 1,470 | 1974-1991 | NYJ |
| 30 | Jay Feely | 1,451 | 2001-2014 | Atl, NYG, Mia, NYJ, Az, Chi |
| 31 | Jim Turner | 1,439 | 1964-1979 | NYJ, Den |
| 32 | Graham Gano | 1,434 | 2009-2025 | Was, Car, NYG |
| 33 | Ryan Succop | 1,430 | 2009-2022 | KC, Ten, TB |
| 34 | Matt Bahr | 1,422 | 1979-1995 | Pit, SF, Cle, NYG, Phi, NE |
| 35 | Jeff Wilkins | 1,416 | 1994-2007 | Phi, SF, SLR |
| 36 | Greg Zuerlein | 1,409 | 2012-2024 | LAR, Dal, NYJ |
| 37 | Josh Brown | 1,395 | 2003-2016 | Sea, SLR, Cin, NYG |
| 38 | Mark Moseley | 1,382 | 1970-1986 | Phi, Oilers, Was, Cle |
| 39 | Jim Bakken | 1,380 | 1962-1978 | SLC |
| 40 | Fred Cox | 1,365 | 1963-1977 | Min |
| 41 | Rian Lindell | 1,350 | 2000-2013 | Sea, Buf, TB |
| 42 | Jason Myers | 1,289 | 2015-2025 | Jax, NYJ, Sea |
| 43 | Brandon McManus | 1,265 | 2014-2025 | Den, Jax, GB |
| 44 | Shayne Graham | 1,260 | 2001-2015 | Buf, Car, Cin, NYG, NE, Mia, Bal, Hou, NO, Atl |
| 45 | Jerry Rice+ | 1,256 | 1985-2004 | SF, Raid, Sea |
| 46 | Chris Boswell | 1,250 | 2015- | Pit |
| 47 | Jim Breech | 1,246 | 1979-1992 | Oak, Cin |
| 48 | Pete Stoyanovich | 1,236 | 1989-2000 | Mia, KC, SLR |
| 49 | Chris Bahr | 1,213 | 1976-1989 | Cin, Raid, SD |
| 50 | Kevin Butler | 1,208 | 1985-1997 | Chi, Az |
