| 2024 | Andrew Van Ginkel (Min) | 2 |
| 2023 | DaRon Bland (Dal) | 5 |
| 2022 | Kyle Dugger (NE) | 2 |
| Kendall Fuller (Was) | 2 |
| 2021 | Trevon Diggs (Dal) | 2 |
| Rasul Douglas (GB) | 2 |
| Mike Edwards (TB) | 2 |
| 2020 | Troy Hill (LAR) | 2 |
| 2019 | Marcus Peters (LAR, Bal) | 3 |
| 2018 | Eddie Jackson (Chi) | 2 |
| Alec Ogletree (NYG) | 2 |
| 2017 | Justin Coleman (Sea) | 2 |
| Jackrabbit Jenkins (NYG) | 2 |
| 2016 | Eric Berry (KC) | 2 |
| Malcolm Jenkins (Phi) | 2 |
| Deion Jones (Atl) | 2 |
| Bradley Roby (Den) | 2 |
| 2015 | Karlos Dansby (Cle) | 2 |
| Reshad Jones (Mia) | 2 |
| Josh Norman (Car) | 2 |
| Marcus Peters (KC) | 2 |
| Aqib Talib (Den) | 2 |
| 2014 | William Gay (Pit) | 3 |
| 2013 | Eric Berry (KC) | 2 |
| Karlos Dansby (Az) | 2 |
| Mason Foster (TB) | 2 |
| DeAngelo Hall (Was) | 2 |
| Tim Jennings (Chi) | 2 |
| Captain Munnerlyn (Car) | 2 |
| 2012 | Jackrabbit Jenkins (StL.Rams) | 3 |
| Charles Tillman (Chi) | 3 |
| 2011 | Brandon Browner (Sea) | 2 |
| Chris Houston (Det) | 2 |
| Aqib Talib (TB) | 2 |
| Charles Tillman (Chi) | 2 |
| 2010 | David Bowens (Cle) | 2 |
| Kelvin Hayden (Ind) | 2 |
| Dwight Lowery (NYJ) | 2 |
| Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie (Az) | 2 |
| 2009 | Darren Sharper (NO) | 3 |
| Charles Woodson (GB) | 3 |
| 2008 | Nick Collins (GB) | 3 |
| 2007 | Antrel Rolle (Az) | 3 |
| 2006 | Ronde Barber (TB) | 2 |
| Chris McAlister (Bal) | 2 |
| Jason Taylor (Mia) | 2 |
| 2005 | Champ Bailey (Den) | 2 |
| Karlos Dansby (Az) | 2 |
| Clinton Hart (SD) | 2 |
| Cato June (Ind) | 2 |
| Darren Sharper (Min) | 2 |
| 2004 | Kevin Mathis (Atl) | 2 |
| Darren Sharper (GB) | 2 |
| Lito Sheppard (Phi) | 2 |
| Takeo Spikes (Buf) | 2 |
| 2003 | Tedy Bruschi (NE) | 2 |
| Phillip Buchanon (Oak) | 2 |
| Andre Dyson (Ten) | 2 |
| Travis Fisher (StL.Rams) | 2 |
| Mike Minter (Car) | 2 |
| Jerome Woods (KC) | 2 |
| 2002 | Derrick Brooks (TB) | 3 |
| 2001 | Dre’ Bly (StL.Rams) | 2 |
| Zack Bronson (SF) | 2 |
| Mike Brown (Chi) | 2 |
| Dexter Coakley (Dal) | 2 |
| Anthony Dorsett (Oak) | 2 |
| Ty Law (NE) | 2 |
| Brock Marion (Mia) | 2 |
| Chad Scott (Pit) | 2 |
| Otis Smith (NE) | 2 |
| Brandon Spoon (Buf) | 2 |
| Aeneas Williams (StL.Rams) | 2 |
| 2000 | Eric Allen (Oak) | 3 |
| 1999 | Donnie Abraham (TB) | 2 |
| Aaron Beasley (Jax) | 2 |
| James Hasty (KC) | 2 |
| Mike Jones (StL.Rams) | 2 |
| George Teague (Dal) | 2 |
| Grant Wistrom (StL.Rams) | 2 |
| Rod Woodson (Bal) | 2 |
| 1998 | Jimmy Hitchcock (Min) | 3 |
| 1997 | Mark McMillian (KC) | 3 |
| Otis Smith (NYJ) | 3 |
| 1996 | Jason Belser (Ind) | 2 |
| Aaron Glenn (NYJ) | 2 |
| Anthony Parker (StL.Rams) | 2 |
| 1995 | Larry Brown (Dal) | 2 |
| Tim McDonald (SF) | 2 |
| Ken Norton Jr. (SF) | 2 |
| Aeneas Williams (Az) | 2 |
| 1994 | Ray Buchanan (Ind) | 3 |
| Deion Sanders (SF) | 3 |
| 1993 | Eric Allen (Phi) | 4 |
| 1992 | Robert Massey (Phoe) | 3 |
| 1991 | Erik McMillan (NYJ) | 2 |
| 1990 | Wayne Haddix (TB) | 3 |
| 1989 | Eddie Anderson (LAR) | 2 |
| Thane Gash (Cle) | 2 |
| 1988 | Carl Lee (Min) | 2 |
| Erik McMillan (NYJ) | 2 |
| 1987 | Ronnie Lippett (NE) | 2 |
| 1986 | Lloyd Burruss (KC) | 3 |
| 1985 | Dave Brown (Sea) | 1 |
| Joey Browner (Min) | 1 |
| Deron Cherry (KC) | 1 |
| Raymond Clayborn (NE) | 1 |
| Jeffery Dale (SD) | 1 |
| Richard Dent (Chi) | 1 |
| Mike Douglass (GB) | 1 |
| Herm Edwards (Phi) | 1 |
| Carl Ekern (LAR) | 1 |
| Leslie Frazier (Chi) | 1 |
| Kerry Glenn (NYJ) | 1 |
| Gary Green (LAR) | 1 |
| Jacob Green (Sea) | 1 |
| James Griffin (Cin) | 1 |
| Al Gross (Cle) | 1 |
| Mike Harden (Den) | 1 |
| Lester Hayes (LAR) | 1 |
| John Hendy (SD) | 1 |
| Terry Hoage (NO) | 1 |
| Wes Hopkins (Phi) | 1 |
| LeRoy Irvin (LAR) | 1 |
| Robert Jackson (Cin) | 1 |
| Jim Jeffcoat (Dal) | 1 |
| Johnnie Johnson (LAR) | 1 |
| William Judson (Mia) | 1 |
| Eugene Lockhart (Dal) | 1 |
| George Martin (NYG) | 1 |
| Mike Merriweather (Pit) | 1 |
| Mark Murphy (GB) | 1 |
| Elvis Patterson (NYG) | 1 |
| Johnnie Poe (NO) | 1 |
| John Rade (Atl) | 1 |
| Mike Richardson (Chi) | 1 |
| Victor Scott (Dal) | 1 |
| Sam Seale (LAR) | 1 |
| Terry Taylor (Sea) | 1 |
| Dennis Thurman (Dal) | 1 |
| Stacey Toran (LAR) | 1 |
| Lionel Washington (StL.Card) | 1 |
| Carlton Williamson (SF) | 1 |
| Otis Wilson (Chi) | 1 |
| 1984 | Dave Brown (Sea) | 2 |
| Gill Byrd (SD) | 2 |
| Vernon Dean (Was) | 2 |
| Kenny Easley (Sea) | 2 |
| LeRoy Irvin (LAR) | 2 |
| Keith Simpson (Sea) | 2 |
| Sam Washington (Pit) | 2 |
| Dirt Winston (NO) | 2 |
| 1983 | Hugh Green (TB) | 2 |
| Dwight Hicks (SF) | 2 |
| Johnnie Johnson (LAR) | 2 |
| Kenny Johnson (Atl) | 2 |
| Mike Kozlowski (Mia) | 2 |
| Rod Martin (LAR) | 2 |
| Ken Riley (Cin) | 2 |
| Eric Wright (SF) | 2 |
| 1982 | Gary Barbaro (KC) | 1 |
| Glenn Blackwood (Mia) | 1 |
| Richard Blackmore (Phi) | 1 |
| Clinton Burrell (Cle) | 1 |
| Jim Burroughs (Bal) | 1 |
| James Davis (LAR) | 1 |
| Mike Davis (LAR) | 1 |
| Gary Green (KC) | 1 |
| Bo Harris (Cin) | 1 |
| Eric Harris (KC) | 1 |
| Bobby Jackson (NYJ) | 1 |
| Ronnie Lott (SF) | 1 |
| Rod Martin (LAR) | 1 |
| Don McNeal (Mia) | 1 |
| Ray Oldham (Det) | 1 |
| Ken Riley (Cin) | 1 |
| Rick Sanford (NE) | 1 |
| Bruce Scholtz (Sea) | 1 |
| Lawrence Taylor (NYG) | 1 |
| Dennis Thurman (Dal) | 1 |
| John Turner (Min) | 1 |
| Otis Wilson (Chi) | 1 |
| 1981 | Ronnie Lott+ (SF) | 3 |
| 1980 | Ray Griffin (Cin) | 2 |
| 1979 | Lester Hayes (Oak) | 2 |
| Woodrow Lowe (SD) | 2 |
| Jim Youngblood (LAR) | 2 |
| 1978 | Rod Perry (LAR) | 3 |
| 1977 | Willie Alexander (Hou) | 1 |
| Gary Barbaro (KC) | 1 |
| Dave Brown (Sea) | 1 |
| Bill Bryant (NYG) | 1 |
| Willie Buchanon (GB) | 1 |
| Greg Buttle (NYJ) | 1 |
| Rick Byas (Atl) | 1 |
| Tim Collier (KC) | 1 |
| Thom Darden (Cle) | 1 |
| Fred Dean (SD) | 1 |
| Thomas Henderson (Dal) | 1 |
| Gerald Irons (Cle) | 1 |
| Tom Jackson (Den) | 1 |
| Greg Johnson (Bal, TB) | 1 |
| Doug Jones (Buf) | 1 |
| Leroy Jones (SD) | 1 |
| George Martin (NYG) | 1 |
| Jim Merlo (NO) | 1 |
| Lemar Parrish (Cin) | 1 |
| Robert Pennywell (Atl) | 1 |
| Reggie Pinkney (Det) | 1 |
| Clarence Scott (Cle) | 1 |
| Mike Sensibaugh (StL.Card) | 1 |
| Mike Washington (TB) | 1 |
| Reggie Williams (Cin) | 1 |
| Richard Wood (TB) | 1 |
| Louis Wright (Den) | 1 |
| Jim Youngblood (LAR) | 1 |
| 1976 | Monte Jackson (LAR) | 3 |
| 1975 | Jackie Wallace (Bal) | 2 |
| 1974 | Dave Elmendorf (LAR) | 2 |
| Levi Johnson (Det) | 2 |
| Emmitt Thomas (KC) | 2 |
| 1973 | Dick Anderson (Mia) | 2 |
| Tom Hayes (Atl) | 2 |
| 1972 | Jim Kearney (KC) | 4 |
| 1971 | Ken Houston (Hou) | 4 |
| 1970 | Lem Barney (Det) | 2 |
| Jerry Logan (Bal) | 2 |
| 1969 | Kenny Graham (AFL, SD) | 2 |
| Eddie Meador (LAR) | 2 |
| Bill Stanfill (AFL, Mia) | 2 |
| 1968 | Joe Beauchamp (AFL, SD) | 2 |
| Booker Edgerson (AFL, Buf) | 2 |
| Miller Farr (AFL, Hou) | 2 |
| Ken Houston (AFL, Hou) | 2 |
| Spider Lockhart (NYG) | 2 |
| Jack Pardee (LAR) | 2 |
| 1967 | Lem Barney (Det) | 3 |
| Miller Farr (AFL, Hou) | 3 |
| 1966 | Tom Janik (AFL, Buf) | 2 |
| Bob Jeter (GB) | 2 |
| Larry Wilson (StL.Card) | 2 |
| 1965 | Herb Adderley (GB) | 3 |
| Dave Grayson (AFL, Oak) | 2 |
| Gus Otto (AFL, Oak) | 2 |
| 1964 | Pat Fischer (StL.Card) | 2 |
| Rip Hawkins (Min) | 2 |
| Bill Baird (NYJ) | 1 |
| Johnny Baker (Hou) | 1 |
| Butch Byrd (Buf) | 1 |
| Earl Faison (SD) | 1 |
| Bobby Hunt (KC) | 1 |
| Tom Janik (Den) | 1 |
| Pete Jaquess (Hou) | 1 |
| Wahoo McDaniel (NYJ) | 1 |
| Benny Nelson (Hou) | 1 |
| Ross O’Hanley (Bos) | 1 |
| Dainard Paulson (NYJ) | 1 |
| Henry Schmidt (SD) | 1 |
| Tom Sestak (Buf) | 1 |
| LaVerne Torczon (NYJ) | 1 |
| 1963 | Dick Lynch (NYG) | 3 |
| Bob Suci (AFL, Bos) | 2 |
| 1962 | Herb Adderley (GB) | 1 |
| Tom Addison (Bos) | 1 |
| Gene Babb (Hou) | 1 |
| Fred Bruney (Bos) | 1 |
| Bill Butler (Min) | 1 |
| Carl Charon (Buf) | 1 |
| Lindon Crow (LAR) | 1 |
| Willie Daniel (Pit) | 1 |
| Don Floyd (Hou) | 1 |
| Wayne Fontes (N.Y.Titans) | 1 |
| Mike Gaechter (Dal) | 1 |
| Claude Gibson (SD) | 1 |
| Goose Gonsoulin (Den) | 1 |
| Ron Hall (Bos) | 1 |
| Dick LeBeau (Det) | 1 |
| John McGeever (Den) | 1 |
| Jim McMillin (Den) | 1 |
| Leroy Moore (Bos, Buf) | 1 |
| Merlin Olsen (LAR) | 1 |
| Richie Petitbon (Chi) | 1 |
| Bob Schmitz (Pit) | 1 |
| Tom Sestak (Buf) | 1 |
| Rosey Taylor (Chi) | 1 |
| Fred Williamson (Oak) | 1 |
| Sam Williams (Det) | 1 |
| Larry Wilson (StL.Card) | 1 |
| Bob Zeman (Den) | 1 |
| 1961 | Dick Harris (SD) | 3 |
| Erich Barnes (NYG) | 2 |
| Dale Hackbart (GB, Was) | 2 |
| Jerry Norton (StL.Card) | 2 |
| Billy Stacy (StL.Card) | 2 |
| 1960 | Bobby Franklin (Cle) | 2 |
| Dave Webster (Dal.Tex) | 2 |
| 1959 | Lindon Crow (NYG) | 1 |
| Milt Davis (Bal) | 1 |
| Night Train Lane (Ch.Card) | 1 |
| Jerry Mertens (SF) | 1 |
| Andy Nelson (Bal) | 1 |
| Bernie Parrish (Cle) | 1 |
| Bill Pellington (Bal) | 1 |
| Richie Petitbon (Chi) | 1 |
| Harland Svare (NYG) | 1 |
| Dick Szymanski (Bal) | 1 |
| 1958 | Will Sherman (LAR) | 2 |
| 1957 | Milt Davis (Bal) | 2 |
| 1956 | J.C. Caroline (Chi) | 2 |
| 1955 | Bibbles Bawel (Phi) | 2 |
| 1954 | Jack Butler (Pit) | 2 |
| Ken Konz (Cle) | 2 |
| 1953 | Chuck Bednarik (Phi) | 1 |
| Rex Berry (SF) | 1 |
| Jack Butler (Pit) | 1 |
| Lew Carpenter (Det) | 1 |
| Jack Christiansen (Det) | 1 |
| Jack Cloud (Was) | 1 |
| Bobby Dillon (GB) | 1 |
| Harry Dowda (Was) | 1 |
| Jack Dwyer (LAR) | 1 |
| Frank Gifford (NYG) | 1 |
| Don Kindt (Chi) | 1 |
| Woodley Lewis (LAR) | 1 |
| Walt Michaels (Cle) | 1 |
| Ray Ramsey (Ch.Card) | 1 |
| Bert Rechichar (Bal) | 1 |
| Herb Rich (LAR) | 1 |
| Leo Sanford (Ch.Card) | 1 |
| Val Joe Walker (GB) | 1 |
| 1952 | Night Train Lane (LAR) | 2 |
| 1951 | Warren Lahr (Cle) | 2 |
| Tom Landry (NYG) | 2 |
| Otto Schnellbacher (NYG) | 2 |
| 1950 | Warren Lahr (Cle) | 2 |
| Bones Weatherly (Chi) | 2 |
| 1949 | Emlen Tunnell (NYG) | 2 |
| Eddie Carr (SF) | 1 |
| Tommy James (Cle) | 1 |
| Bill Johnson (SF) | 1 |
| Pete Layden (NYY) | 1 |
| Martin Ruby (NYY) | 1 |
| Lou Saban (Cle) | 1 |
| Lowell Wagner (SF) | 1 |
| Ab Wimberly (L.A.Dons) | 1 |
| Dick Woodard (L.A.Dons) | 1 |
| 1948 | Bill Blackburn (Ch.Card) | 2 |
| Joe Golding (Bos) | 2 |
| Dan Sandifer (Was) | 2 |
| Carl Allen (Bkn) | 1 |
| Eddie Carr (SF) | 1 |
| Paul Crowe (SF) | 1 |
| Walt Heap (L.A.Dons) | 1 |
| Vince Mazza (Buf.Bisons) | 1 |
| Bill Reinhard (LAD) | 1 |
| Otto Schnellbacher (NYY) | 1 |
| Carl Schuette (Buf.Bisons) | 1 |
| 1947 | Tony Compagno (Pit) | 2 |
| Bill Schroeder (Ch.Rock) | 2 |
| 1946 | Chet Adams (Cle) | 1 |
| Ki Aldrich (Was) | 1 |
| Ed Balatti (SF) | 1 |
| Stu Clarkson (Chi) | 1 |
| Bill Dudley (Pit) | 1 |
| Steve Filipowicz (NYG) | 1 |
| Frank Gatski (Cle) | 1 |
| Otto Graham (Cle) | 1 |
| Tom Harmon (LAR) | 1 |
| Steve Juzwik (Buf.Bisons) | 1 |
| Mike Micka (Bos) | 1 |
| Bob Nowaskey (LAD) | 1 |
| Spec Sanders (NYY) | 1 |
| Gil Steinke (Phi) | 1 |
| Ray Terrell (Cle) | 1 |
| Walt Williams (Ch.Rock) | 1 |
| 1945 | Charley Brock (GB) | 2 |
| 1944 | Don Perkins (GB) | 2 |
| Bill Petrilas (NYG) | 2 |
| 1943 | Larry Cabrelli (Phi) | 1 |
| Irv Comp (GB) | 1 |
| Harry Hopp (Det) | 1 |
| Don Hutson (GB) | 1 |
| Ben Kish (Phi) | 1 |
| Lou Rymkus (Was) | 1 |
| Frankie Sinkwich (Det) | 1 |
| Len Younce (NYG) | 1 |
| 1942 | Neal Adams (NYG) | 1 |
| Merl Condit (Bkn) | 1 |
| Bob Ingalls (GB) | 1 |
| Sid Luckman (Chi) | 1 |
| Champ Seibold (Ch.Card) | 1 |
| Bulldog Turner (Chi) | 1 |
| George Wilson (Chi) | 1 |
| 1941 | Victor Carroll (Was) | 1 |
| Hugh Gallarneau (Chi) | 1 |
| Pop Ivy (Ch.Card) | 1 |
| Pug Manders (Bkn) | 1 |
| Ned Mathews (Det) | 1 |
| Doug Oldershaw (NYG) | 1 |
| Bob Swisher (Chi) | 1 |
| Hal Van Every (GB) | 1 |
| Whizzer White (Det) | 1 |
| 1940 | Bob Adkins (GB) | 1 |
| Tony Calvelli (Det) | 1 |
| Harry Clarke (Chi) | 1 |
| Johnny Hall (Ch.Card) | 1 |
| Jack Haman (Cl.Rams) | 1 |
| Jimmy Johnston (Was) | 1 |
| Ace Parker (Bkn) | 1 |
| Vic Spadaccini (Cl.Rams) | 1 |
| Alex Wojciechowicz (Det) | 1 |
| 1939 | Charley Brock (GB) | 1 |
| Jerry Dowd (Cl.Rams) | 1 |
| Herman Hodges (Bkn) | 1 |
| Sid Luckman (Chi) | 1 |
| Bob MacLeod (Chi) | 1 |
| Ray Nolting (Chi) | 1 |
| Solly Sherman (Chi) | 1 |
| Hank Soar (NYG) | 1 |
| 1938 | Jay Arnold (Phi) | 1 |
| George Corbett (Chi) | 1 |
| Ward Cuff (NYG) | 1 |
| Phil Dougherty (Ch.Card) | 1 |
| Chuck Gelatka (24) | 1 |
| Mel Hein (29) | 1 |
| Joe Laws (GB) | 1 |
| Ace Parker (Bkn) | 1 |
| Joe Zeller (Ci) | 1 |
| 1937 | Cliff Battles (Was) | 1 |
| Bill Davidson (Pit) | 1 |
| Sam Francis (Chi) | 1 |
| Buckets Goldenberg (GB) | 1 |
| Maurice Harper (Phi) | 1 |
| Vern Huffman (Det) | 1 |
| Tom Hupke (Det) | 1 |
| Ed Jankowski (GB) | 1 |
| Jack Manders (Chi) | 1 |
| Eggs Manske (Chi) | 1 |
| Bill Shepherd (Det) | 1 |
| Riley Smith (Was) | 1 |
| Hank Soar (NYG) | 1 |
| 1936 | Pug Rentner (Bos) | 2 |
| 1935 | Johnny Blood (GB) | 1 |
| Hank Bruder (GB) | 1 |
| Cal Hubbard (GB) | 1 |
| Eddie Kawal (Chi) | 1 |
| Bo Molenda (NYG) | 1 |
| George Sauer Sr. (GB) | 1 |
| Art Strutt (Pit) | 1 |
| 1934 | Hank Bruder (GB) | 1 |
| Ernie Caddel (Det) | 1 |
| Swede Hanson (Phi) | 1 |
| Father Lumpkin (Det) | 1 |
| Jack Manders (Chi) | 1 |
| 1933 | Dale Burnett (NYG) | 1 |
| Wuert Engelmann (GB) | 1 |
| Buckets Goldenberg (GB) | 1 |
| Marty Kottler (Pit) | 1 |
| Ernie Pinckert (Bos) | 1 |
| Ken Strong (NYG) | 1 |
| Lee Woodruff (Phi) | 1 |
| 1932 | Johnny Blood (GB) | 1 |
| John Cavosie (Por) | 1 |
| Wuert Engelmann (GB) | 1 |
| Arnie Herber (GB) | 1 |
| Luke Johnson (Chi) | 1 |
| Al Rose (GB) | 1 |
