| 1 | Rod Woodson+ | 12 | 1987-2003 | Pit, SF, Bal, Oak |
| 2 | Darren Sharper | 11 | 1997-2010 | GB, Min, NO |
| | Charles Woodson+ | 11 | 1998-2015 | Oak, GB |
| 4 | Aqib Talib | 10 | 2008-2019 | TB, NE, Den, LAR |
| 5 | Ken Houston+ | 9 | 1967-1980 | Hou. Oilers, Was |
| | Deion Sanders+ | 9 | 1989-2005 | Atl, SF, Dal, Was, Bal |
| | Aeneas Williams+ | 9 | 1991-2004 | Az, SLR |
| 8 | Eric Allen+ | 8 | 1988-2001 | Phi, NO, Oak |
| | Ronde Barber+ | 8 | 1997-2012 | TB |
| | Jackrabbit Jenkins | 8 | 2012-2022 | SLR, NYG, NO, Ten, SF |
| | Charles Tillman | 8 | 2003-2015 | Chi, Car |
| 12 | Herb Adderley+ | 7 | 1961-1972 | GB, Dal |
| | Erich Barnes | 7 | 1958-1971 | Chi, NYG, Cle |
| | Lem Barney+ | 7 | 1967-1977 | Det |
| | Malcolm Jenkins | 7 | 2009-2021 | NO, Phi |
| | Johnathan Joseph | 7 | 2006-2020 | Cin, Hou, Ten, Az |
| | Ty Law+ | 7 | 1995-2009 | NE, NYJ, KC, Den |
| | Marcus Peters | 7 | 2015-2023 | KC, LAR, Bal, LV |
| | Ed Reed+ | 7 | 2002-2013 | Bal, Hou, NYJ |
| | Otis Smith | 7 | 1991-2003 | Phi, NYJ, NE, Det |
| 21 | Bobby Bell+ | 6 | 1963-1974 | KC |
| | DaRon Bland | 6 | 2022-2025 | Dal |
| | Derrick Brooks+ | 6 | 1995-2008 | TB |
| | Terrell Buckley | 6 | 1992-2005 | GB, Mia, Den, NE, NYJ, NYG |
| | Karlos Dansby | 6 | 2004-2017 | Az, Mia, Cle, Cin |
| | Miller Farr | 6 | 1965-1973 | Den, SD, Oilers, SLC, Det |
| | Aaron Glenn | 6 | 1994-2008 | NYJ, Hou, Dal, Jax, NO |
| | Darrell Green+ | 6 | 1983-2002 | Was |
| | Tom Janik | 6 | 1963-1971 | Den, Buf, NE |
| | Terry McDaniel | 6 | 1988-1998 | Raid, Sea |
| | Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie | 6 | 2008-2019 | Az, Phi, Den, NYG, Oak, Was |
| | Asante Samuel | 6 | 2003-2013 | NE, Phi, Atl |
| 33 | Eric Berry | 5 | 2010-2018 | KC |
| | Johnny Blood+ | 5 | 1925-1938 | Mil, Dul, Pot, GB, Pit |
| | Dre’ Bly | 5 | 1999-2009 | SLR, Det, Den, SF |
| | Lance Briggs | 5 | 2003-2014 | Chi |
| | Dave Brown | 5 | 1975-1989 | Pit, Sea, GB |
| | Phillip Buchanon | 5 | 2002-2011 | Oak, Hou, TB, Det, Was |
| | Butch Byrd | 5 | 1964-1971 | Buf, Den |
| | Nate Clements | 5 | 2001-2012 | Buf, SF, Cin |
| | Bobby Dillon+ | 5 | 1952-1959 | GB |
| | William Gay | 5 | 2007-2017 | Pit, Az |
| | Kenny Graham | 5 | 1964-1970 | SD, Cin, Pit |
| | Dave Grayson | 5 | 1961-1970 | KC, Oak |
| | DeAngelo Hall | 5 | 2004-2017 | Atl, Oak, Was |
| | Dick Harris | 5 | 1960-1965 | SD |
| | Jimmy Hitchcock | 5 | 1995-2002 | NE, Min, Car |
| | LeRoy Irvin | 5 | 1980-1990 | LAR, Det |
| | Deion Jones | 5 | 2016-2025 | Atl, Cle, Car, TB |
| | Jim Kearney | 5 | 1965-1976 | Det, KC, NO |
| | Warren Lahr | 5 | 1949-1959 | Cle |
| | Dick Night Train Lane+ | 5 | 1952-1965 | LAR, Chi. Cardinals, Det |
| | Darryll Lewis | 5 | 1991-2000 | Ten, SD |
| | Jerry Logan | 5 | 1963-1972 | Bal. Colts |
| | Ronnie Lott+ | 5 | 1981-1994 | SF, Raid, NYJ |
| | Chris McAlister | 5 | 1999-2009 | Bal, NO |
| | Erik McMillan | 5 | 1988-1993 | NYJ, Phi, Cle, KC |
| | Eddie Meador | 5 | 1959-1970 | LAR |
| | Captain Munnerlyn | 5 | 2009-2018 | Car, Min |
| | Jack Pardee | 5 | 1957-1972 | LAR, Was |
| | Ken Riley+ | 5 | 1969-1983 | Cin |
| | Emmitt Thomas+ | 5 | 1966-1978 | KC |
| | Dewayne Washington | 5 | 1994-2005 | Min, Pit, Jax, KC |
| | Larry Wilson+ | 5 | 1960-1972 | SLC |
